Wednesday, 18 November 2026

The Geology Around Coombs Dale

 
A chert nodule in the Monsal Dale Limestone Formation

Since alighting from the No. 65 bus on The Avenue, I had spent and hour and fifty minutes walking around Stoney Middleton to undertake a British Listed Buildings Photo Challenge and, after noting a small outcrop of reef limestone belonging to the Eyam Limestone Formation (ELF), I set off along Eaton Fold on the way to Coombs Dale. 
 
The geology around Coombs Dale

Although I didn’t notice this at the time, the geological map shows that at about 55 m along Eaton Fold, the underlying bedrock changes from the ELF to the younger Bowland Shale Formation and, approximately 80 m further along the track, this is covered by Mid Pleistocene glacial till. 
 
A panoramic view from Eaton Fold
 
Stopping briefly to take in the panoramic views from the track, the Shale Grit forms a wooded escarpment in the mid distance beyond Stoney Middleton to the NNE, with the Chatsworth Grit forming Curbar Edge and Froggatt Edge on the skyline to the east. 
 
The topography of the area Stoney Middleton and Curbar Edge
 
From this viewpoint, the topography of the area isn't fully appreciated, which includes the Derwent Valley that runs north to south beneath the west facing gritstone edges, or the landslips that are are common in the lowermost strata of the Millstone Grit Group in Derbyshire.
 
The Old Vicarage

Passing the Grade II listed Old Vicarage (1834), which is built with well squared and coursed gritstone that was probably quarried from the Chatsworth Grit, I continued along the track to the point where it diverges into two footpaths that lead to Coombs Dale. 
 
A sign for the public footpaths to Coombs Dale
 
Taking the southern path, which continues across the glacial till through limestone grassland, I was very surprised to see that a substantial part of the upper slopes of Coombs Dale are covered in gorse, which I associated with the acidic soils that form on sandstones. 

Gorse on the upper slope of Coombs Dale

Coombs Dale is designated as a biological Site of Special Scientific Interest, for its very diverse and often rare flora and invertebrates, and the description refers to soils that have been leached of their calcium carbonate, which results in the formation of neutral or acidic soils where the species of gorse, Ulex europaeus, is able to thrive. 
 
Gorse next to the public footpath down to Coombs Dale
 
Descending further down the path into the dale, it became very clear that gorse not only grows in the leached soil, but also around the outcrops of the Monsal Dale Limestone Formation (MDLF) that are exposed in this part of Coombs Dale. 
 
An outcrop of the MDLF
 
When contracted by Derbyshire Wildlife Trust to survey the RIGS (Regionally Important Geological Sites) back in August 1995, on behalf of the Peak National Park Planning Authority and English Nature, the main reason for my visit was to look at the Hob’s House Coral Band. 
 
An outcrop of the MDLF with bands of chert

At that time, I wasn’t using a GPS device and my photos were restricted to just 9 colour transparencies that mainly record the details of colonial corals that I found. Although during my latest visit I wasn’t able to pinpoint the locations where I found these, I did find several good exposures of nodules and bands of  chert. 
 
Thin bands and nodules of chert
 
I still had to walk to Calver, so I didn’t spend much time closely examining each outcrop but, when walking further along Coombs Dale to look at outcrops that seemed familiar, I had a quick look for corals but I did not find any. 
 
An outcrop of the MDLF

When undertaking a recce for a Sheffield U3A Geology Group field trip to Cressbrook Dale, the previous year, Stuart and I could not find corals in the MDLF that I had identified in 1995. Without maps and grid references this is not always easy but, when several members of the group were looking for them during the actual field trip, a few examples were found 
 
Solution hollows in the MDLF

Although I didn't locate the Hob’s House Coral Band on this occasion, I had seen this at its type locality in Monsal Dale where silicified colonial and solitary corals are spectacularly preserved; however, I did find one outcrop where there were numerous small solution hollows in a bed of micritic limestone, which I had not encountered before. 
 
A specimen of micritic limestone
 
With my Estwing hammer, I obtained a couple of small samples that are essentially micritic and, when viewed with a hand lens, one has a siliceous appearance, as I had seen during my last visit to Ashford-in-the-Water, with the other containing a fossil mould of a brachiopod where a trace of its ribbed shell can be seen.
 
A specimen of limestone with a mould of a brachiopod shell
 

Tuesday, 17 November 2026

Stoney Middleton Revisited - Part 3

 
A view from Eaton Fold in Stoney Middleton

Continuing my exploration of Stoney Middleton, where I had seen a few exposures of the Eyam Limestone Formation (ELF) and photographed a handful of historic buildings as part of a British Listed Buildings Photo Challenge, I had a quick look at St. Martin’s church. 
 
A view of St. Martin's church from The Nook

I had briefly visited the church back in 2019 and was particularly interested in the memorial to Reverend Urban Smith. This has a central panel of inscribed Italian Carrara marble, a surround comprising squares of several varieties of Carboniferous Limestone, with borders and squares of Ashford Black marble, hemispheres of fluorite and framed with alabaster. 
 
The memorial to Reverend Urban Smith
 
The description of the History of the Village of Stoney Middleton by Thomas E Cowen (1910) states that Reverend Smith was a noted geologist and that some of the specimens in his own rock collection have been incorporated into this memorial. 
 
An extract from the History of the Village of Stoney Middleton

Since first visiting St. Martin’s church, I had been invited to give an illustrated talk to celebrate the 150th anniversary of the consecration of St. Peter’s church in Edensor – on the subject of “The Devonshire Marbles”. Although the COVID-19 Pandemic led to this being cancelled and the promised rescheduling did not come to fruition, I wanted to have another look at the limestones. 
 
A detail of the memorial to Reverend Urban Smith
 
Stoney Middleton was historically part of the estate owned by the Duke of Devonshire and the 6th Duke, William Cavendish (1790-1858), gave several samples of decorative stone quarried on the estate to Faustino Corsini (1771-1846), whose Corsini Collection of stones is now housed at the Oxford University Museum of Natural History. 
 
A detail of the memorial to Reverend Urban Smith

Looking at some of the limestones in the Corsi Collection, specimen 286 from One Ash Grange and specimen 287 from an unidentified location are described as bioturbated and have similar textures to a couple of the limestones in Reverend Smith’s memorial, with specimen 288 from Millers Dale contains corals. 
 
A detail of the memorial to Reverend Urban Smith
 
It has been suggested to me by Clare Herbert - the former manager of the Peak District Mining Museum - that Hopton Wood limestone, which has light beige and dark varieties, might have been used for a couple of the squares. Sheffield Town Hall has used the light beige variety in the main hall and both light and dark varieties have been used in Sheffield City Hall, but I can’t recall seeing stone that has both variations. 
 
A headstone in St.Martin's churchyard

Leaving the church, I then had a quick wander around the churchyard and was quite surprised by the large size of many of the headstones, but I was mainly interested in trying to get a view of The Hall, which Historic England describes as “Early C17, remodelled in mid C18, restored and refashioned in early C19”. 
 
The Hall
 
The Hall is surrounded by a high boundary wall and the garden has several mature trees and dense shrubs that obscure the view, but I managed to take a couple of photos that would satisfy the requirements of my Photo Challenge.
 
The Hall
 
Making my way back along The Nook, I stopped briefly to take a photo of Dale Brook, which powered wheels that operated bellows at lead smelter and a corn mill upstream and has been channelled to run alongside Denham Cottage and its attached outbuilding. 
 
Dale Brook
 
Continuing along The Nook, the next building on my Photo Challenge was No. 3, an early C19 house that is building entirely with Millstone Grit and is only Grade II listed for its group value – as with Spa Cottage and Brook Cottages that I had seen earlier on my walk. 
 
No. 3 The Nook

Crossing over The Avenue, I then headed up High Street, which the Stone Middleton Heritage Trail information board states “must be the steepest High Street in the country and was the only route through the village before a road was blasted through Middleton Dale in 1830”. 
 
Pine View
 
The Grade II listed Pine View, which comprises a row of three C17 terraced houses, built with a mixture of limestone and gritstone, with its original stone slate roof, but with render applied to the east and west elevations. 
 
The Stoney Middleton Church of England Primary School
 
On the opposite side of the road is the Stoney Middleton Church of England Primary School, which is built with limestone walls with gritstone quoins and dressings. Two gritstone plaques are set into the gable, with inscriptions that say that the school was originally built by subscription in 1835 and subsequently enlarged in 1845. 
 
Inscribed plaques
 
I continued up High Street to Eaton Fold past various cottages that are marked on the 1883 Ordnance Survey map, having walked a distance of 190 m from The Avenue with a change in elevation from 152 m to 176 m – an angle of 7.87 degrees according to the Google AI tool. 
 
A view up High Street

Turning left into Eaton Fold, I immediately encountered a small outcrop of flat reef limestone within the ELF, which overlies the micritic limestone that I had earlier seen along The Avenue and The Bank. Having taking a photograph of this, I then carried along the track to find the public footpath that would take me to Coombs Dale.
 
An outcrop of the ELF on Eaton Fold
 

Thursday, 12 November 2026

Stoney Middleton Revisited - Part 2

 
A Stoney Middleton Heritage Trail information board

Continuing along The Bank in Stoney Middleton, I passed the Grade II Listed Old Malt House which, unlike its rendered 5 storied rear elevation, still has exposed stonework that provides another example of Carboniferous Limestone used for walling and Millstone Grit for the dressings.
 
An outcrop of the ELF to the west of Sunnybank
 
On the opposite side of the road, a small outcrop of the Eyam Limestone Formation (ELF) forms the foundation of a garden wall and next to this is Sunnybank which, according to The Move Market website, was built between 1976 and 1982 and has polygonal rubble walling – a very unusual style of masonry that I had seen on the corner of Doncaster Road/Highfield Lane in Conisbrough on my last day out.
 
Sunnybank
 
This house was built before the Stoney Middleton Conservation Area was established in 1987, which would now require the walling to conform to the style of the rest of the houses along The Bank, where the limestone is squared and coursed to various degrees.
 
The house on the corner of The Bank and The Nook
 
Walking further down The Bank, the house on the corner with The Nook caught my eye, where the render on the gable end – as seen on the 2021 version of Google Map – has been removed. It has an architectural style like other buildings of a similar age, which I have seen in Derbyshire, and I am quite surprised that it is not listed.
 
Another view of the house on the corner of The Bank and The Nook
 
I then had a quick look at the various buildings on Mill Street, which include the rear elevations of the Old Malt House and Brook Cottages and the east elevation of the former flour mill that is now occupied by William Lennon & Co, with limestone used for walling and gritstone for dressings – although the rear of Nos 1 and 2 Dale Brook View is built with gritstone, except for the ground floor.
 
Views of the buildings on Mill Street
 
The next building on my British Listed Buildings Photo Challenge was the Grade II listed early C19 Brook House on The Nook, which is built with squared and coursed walling with gritstone dressings. This three storied house is clearly of a better quality than the cottages along The Bank, with its moulded doorcase and bracketted stone hood, circular headed first floor window with keystone and canted bay window.
 
Brook House

Next on my list was Denham Cottage and the attached agricultural outbuilding, which Historic England (HE) date to the C17, with C18 and C19 alterations. It is built with quite well coursed and squared gritstone, with the outbuilding retaining its original stone slate roof.
 
Denham Cottage

Dale Brook runs alongside the north elevation of the building and, as where it is seen in other parts of village, its course has been channelled. At Grove Gardens, the now infilled mill pond powered the corn mill and, according to the Stoney Middle Heritage Centre website, was diverted to a waterwheel that powered bellows used for lead smelting.
 
The outbuilding at Denham Cottages

Continuing along The Nook past St. Martin’s church, on the left hand side before the road turns sharply to the east, there is an old well with a gritstone bowl, which is the site of the main well dressing in Stoney Middleton.
 
The well on The Nook
 
Further along The Nook, I then came to a structure locally known as the Roman Bath House, but the attached plaque states that there is no evidence of a Roman building being established here, with it most likely to have been built C.1815 by Lord Denman, who was the owner of the nearby Stoney Middleton Hall.

The Roman Bath House
 
Immediately next to the Roman Bath House is a natural spring that the geological map shows is on the junction of the flat reef facies of the ELF and the shales of the Bowland Shale Formation, which forms the lowest part of the Millstone Grit Group.
 
The spring
 
This spring, which fed the bath house with water that has a consistent temperature of 18 degrees centigrade, is marked on the 1897 25 inch OS map as Mineral Tepid Spring. Presumably, a pipe tapped the water from the spring to take it to the bath house, as the well established course of the spring is from north to south and passes through the boundary wall to a drain on The Nook.
 
The spring and drain at The Nook

Just beyond the spring, I was interested to see that the pair of semi-detached houses, which appear on the 1922 OS map, are built with a gritstone that is distinctly reddened. This colouration is not a feature of any of the gritstone walling or dressings that I had so far seen in the village.
 
Semi-detached houses built with reddened gritstone

I then set off up the track to the extension to St. Martin’s churchyard, where I had identified the Commonwealth War Graves Commission (CWGC) headstones of Serjeant A.J. Jerram of the Grenadier Guards and Driver T.G. Pinder of the Royal Engineers.
 
A view of the extension to St. Martin's churchyard

Stancliffe Darley Dale stone has been used for the former and limestone for the latter, but I didn’t examine the limestone closely and I can’t tell from my photos if it is Portland stone or Hopton Wood limestone, which are the English limestones used for CWGC headstones.
 
The headstone of Serjeant A.J. Jerram

I am much more familiar with Portland stone, as seen in many historic buildings and hundreds of CWGC headstones, but its texture and distribution of shell fragments doesn’t look typical. At the cemeteries in Staveley and Brimington, headstones where I initially thought Portland stone is used are in fact made with Hopton Wood limestone, which I realised when seeing crinoids in enlarged my photos, but I don’t see these on this headstone.
 
The headstone of driver T.G. Pinder